Buying a used car is a budget-friendly way to get behind the wheel, but be careful which model you choose when second-hand vehicle shopping. This article focuses on the 19 most unreliable, problematic, and costly-to-repair cars that we don’t recommend you invest in without a manufacturer’s warranty unless you’re a mechanic who simply loves a challenge!
Ford Ranger (2019)
The 2019 Ford Ranger marked the return of the mid-size truck to the American market after a dip in its popularity. It was largely well received at the time—practical, fun to drive, and compact. However, since then, it’s proved less than reliable. Consumer Reports lists it as the most likely used American vehicle to incur repair costs.
Chrysler 200 (2011–2014)
The Chrysler 200 from these model years suffers from a multitude of problems and consistently ranks poorly in reliability surveys. Many owners now report ongoing issues with the transmission, electrical systems, and powertrain, with some even complaining that the substantial repair costs exceed the car’s value! It’s more cost-effective to choose an alternative model.
Nissan Versa (2012–2017)
Nissan is known for producing budget-friendly, yet practical and reliable, cars—but think twice before buying a second-hand Versa model. Their rapid depreciation can make them temptingly affordable as a used choice, but they’re consistently accused of being undependable and of poor quality. The continuously variable transmission (CVT) is especially problematic!
Fiat 500 (2011–2014)
The iconic Fiat 500 isn’t for everyone, but second-hand car buyers may be lured in by its unique, cute shape and small size. Don’t be fooled—the model is known to be a frustrating car to own. The engine, transmission, and infotainment systems often develop faults, whereas parts can be challenging and costly to obtain, particularly if they have to be shipped from Italy!
Dodge Journey (2011–2020)
The Dodge Journey is a popular choice for families due to its spacious size and versatility, but out-of-warranty examples can be expensive to own and maintain. CarParts.com warns that these vehicles are often plagued by “interior water leaks, a malfunctioning remote keyless entry system, an overheating engine, head gasket damage, and premature wear on brakes.”
Ford Fiesta (2011–2019)
The Ford Fiesta was once a popular subcompact choice, but automatic cars made from 2011–19 suffered multiple problems due to their unique “PowerShift” transmission. While Ford warranties covered new owners, second-hand buyers may now have to contend with unpredictably jerky gear changes, premature shifting, and expensive repairs to fix such issues.
BMW X5 (2000–2006)
Owning a large, luxury SUV may seem like a dream come true for used-car buyers, who are often unable to afford such a vehicle from the dealership. Be aware that earlier models of the BMW X5 can turn into “money pits” due to costly and continuingly necessary repairs. Their complex engines and electronics and unreliable engine cooling systems are to blame.
Land Rover Range Rover Evoque (2011–2017)
Another luxury SUV to avoid, this iconic status symbol model isn’t worth the trouble. Indeed, CarDealer says the brand produces the most unreliable used cars of all! Evoque owners have reported numerous problems, including engine failures, suspension problems, and glitchy infotainment systems. They’re also notorious for being expensive to service.
Chevrolet Malibu (2013–2016)
The Chevrolet Malibu is familiar on American roads, but try to avoid models from specific years. Malibus, built between 2013 and 2016, received low marks for reliability, with owners often experiencing issues with the engine, transmission, and electrical system. Such problems cannot be ignored (they almost always make the car undrivable) and can result in hefty repair bills.
Ram 1500 Pick-up (2010–2012)
Ram pick-up trucks, famous for their power and durability, might seem like a great used car option. However, earlier examples of the Ram 1500 were subject to multiple recalls for problems with their brakes, suspension, and electrical systems. Some faulty vehicles slipped through the cracks, though, so make sure you don’t accidentally purchase one of those!
Volkswagen Jetta (2014–2016)
The Volkswagen Jetta is a popular compact sedan, with its German manufacturer often being associated with reliability. Unfortunately, the Jetta was impacted by the Dieselgate emissions scandal—equipped with diesel engines that were programmed to cheat emissions tests. While Volkswagen offered buybacks and repairs for these vehicles, the controversy can make it challenging to sell them later on.
GMC Acadia (2011–2013, 2016–2017, 2020)
Despite being comfortable, spacious, and packed with luxury features, this mid-size SUV isn’t known for its reliability throughout its production history. Owners complain of engine problems, transmission failures, and temperamental infotainment systems. The 2020 model year, in particular, faced issues with the fuel system that resulted in a recall.
Jeep Compass (2017–2018)
The Jeep Compass is a popular choice for those seeking a stylish and capable SUV, but make sure you are aware of its woeful reliability score before purchasing one second-hand. Drivers with 2017–18 examples often suffer transmission, engine, and electrical system failures. They regularly wait a long time for expensive repairs to get their vehicles back on the road.
Kia Soul (2010–2013)
Tempted by the Kia Soul with its funky, cubic design and impressive cargo space? The budget-friendly price tag may be appealing, but you should certainly avoid certain years. Earlier models are notoriously unreliable, with lower-than-average safety scores. Complaints include engine and transmission problems and sub-standard interiors that fail or break easily.
Nissan Juke (2011–2017)
The Nissan Juke is a quirky, stand-out mini SUV that’s affordable and widely available. However, its unconventional design results in limited rear seat space and compromised visibility, making parking dings and bumper dents a common feature of second-hand examples. They also have unreliable transmissions, electrical faults, and glitchy infotainment systems.
Chrysler Pacifica (2017)
Although Pacificas, in general, rate 71/100 (average) for reliability, Vehicle History doesn’t recommend the 2017 model due to its multiple known mechanical issues. While comfortable and feature-packed, choose a minivan from an alternative year, or else you may encounter expensive transmission, electrical, and infotainment issues.
Buick Encore (2013–2015)
The Buick Encore is a subcompact SUV with a luxurious interior and smooth ride, but specific years are associated with a lack of dependability. As with other cars on this list, costly problems affecting various systems have been reported. Additionally, Encores from 2013–15 have lower safety ratings than other years, making them riskier for both your wallet and your health.
Chevrolet Cruze (2011–2015)
Once a popular compact car option, the Cruze’s reputation was tarnished by models manufactured from 2011 to 2015. Problems with the engines, transmissions, and in-car electrics forced Chevrolet to issue a number of recalls, leaving second-hand owners facing hefty repair fees to get their vehicles working again. Go for a model from 2016 or later instead.
Scion FR-S (2013–2016)
Also known as the Subaru BRZ after 2016, the earlier Scion FR-S is a sporty, rear-wheel-drive coupe known to be a lot of fun to drive. While driver enjoyment is undoubtedly an important factor, don’t neglect affordability! These cars are expensive to maintain due to their high-performance engines, and the infotainment system is largely considered to be outdated and clunky.
Read More: 18 Misunderstood Acts The Bible Says Aren’t Actually Sins
People tend to assume that the Bible condemns a wide array of behaviors, but the reality might surprise you. Here, we zoom in on 18 so-called “sins” that may not be as bad as we thought.
18 Misunderstood Acts The Bible Says Aren’t Actually Sins
18 Things You’re Far Too Old To Be Doing Anymore
As we grow older, it’s a great time to reevaluate our choices and habits. In this article, we’ll explore 18 things you may still be doing even though you may be too old.
18 Things You’re Far Too Old To Be Doing Anymore
18 Things That Become Intolerable as You Get Older
As people age, they sometimes don’t find as much joy in things as they used to. An internet survey recently asked, “What are you starting to dislike more as you get older?” Here are the top 19 responses.
18 Things That Become Intolerable as You Get Older
The Boomers Called It: 19 Stupid Trends That Backfired
Sometimes, we get carried away with trends that we think are cool at the time, only to realize later how utterly ridiculous they were. Join us as we take a cringe-worthy trip down memory lane and explore 19 stupid trends that backfired. Prepare for some facepalms!
The Boomers Called It: 19 Stupid Trends That Backfired
21 Things That Will Be Lost Forever When The Boomer Generation is Gone
Baby boomers grew up in a vastly different culture, so they have what younger generations consider strange habits. An internet survey recently asked, “What will die with boomers?” Here are the top 22 answers.
21 Things That Will Be Lost Forever When The Boomer Generation is Gone